Can Avg Cost be used instead of FIFO?

@acamp mentioned it here.

We are now however well into the tax year so an update would be much appreciated.

6 Likes

He didn’t say which new tax year :laughing: - could be a decade down the line

5 Likes

Keep voting people. Freetrade is useless for properly determining profit / loss without it.

7 Likes

bumpity bump

1 Like

Things that happened in February 2023:

  • TInvest formulated this post
  • Nicola Strugeon resigned
  • Horrific earthquake in Turkey and Syria
  • US invaded by Chinese ā€œspyā€ balloons
  • UK energy crisis

Things that didnt happen since Feb 2023

  • Resolution to this annoying FIFO feature

:slight_smile:

12 Likes

Bumping this since Patryk spammed the boards :grimacing:

1 Like

The fact that it’s been over a month of us trying to get someone’s attention to reply to this thread and still nothing say it all.

So much for listening to their customer and shareholders!
Something as fundamental as this should have been sorted out by now.

@acamp

5 Likes

There’s 51 votes, you’re entitled to your opinion but this is a really small issue, Freetrade have far bigger priorities at the moment with the roll out of other features.

@Mattywallace I mean it was mentioned here that it would be sorted out early this tax year we are way pass that.

All I’m asking for is an update or response from someone rather than just being ignored.

2 Likes

Hi @bhav

We’ve taken note of this and know that there’s demand from customers for more flexibility in how we show your entry prices on positions built through multiple orders.

Since the start of the year we’ve really focused in on a number of much needed improvements while (unfortunately) needing to put many useful ones on the back burner for now.

I don’t have a timeline for you on this but we will update here when that changes.

4 Likes

With respect Alex, this in my view isnt one of those ā€˜nice things to have’, but rather crucial. I imagine a number of people will have sold their holdings because the FIFO system incorrectly showed they were up, when they might have been flat or in the red.

If I can be told why I should add all my buys and sells to another website (Sharesight), in order to keep an accurate record of my average price, then I’d happily wait.

9 Likes

I would agree.

I don’t know what % of FreeTrade customers are UK based, but I believe it is a high percentage.

For UK customers, it isn’t about providing more options to show average prices. It is correcting a display that is fundamentally wrong.

12 Likes

They (FT) must think there are a fruit and veg stall in the market - where you want to get rid (I mean sell) off the oldest item first :joy:
Otherwise it makes zero sense.
Also regardless of % of UK customer, FT is an UK company first. It started here - so you would expect it to follow best practices for UK but they chose FIFO instead.
Hey ho!

8 Likes

This I why I don’t think it has as many votes as it should do, as with all respect I’m not convinced that your standard investor is aware of the potential implications.

7 Likes

I’m glad this thread is attracting so much attention.

Having to track my actual AVG in an Excel spreadsheet shouldn’t be necessary.

Again, this change is an easy one to implement. Why it’s taking so long is hilarious to me.

If I were to put my skeptical hat on, I could easily assume that letting customers think they’re making a loss when they’re really making a gain is more profitable, because it generates extra trading commission revenue for Freetrade when people mistakenly sell their positions… It’s not a wild assumption to make…

2 Likes

Do you know why I think it is?

Because most of the FT team aren’t experienced investors - and most of the users don’t understand tax rules and realise how important it is.

4 Likes

This is the likely answer.

When I initially emailed about it, the person I was emailing fundamentally didn’t understand. They kept referring to ā€˜what the average price of my holding is NOW’. Totally missing the point.

4 Likes

I want this as well and because I want it,

this now has to be implemented.

Come on freetrade you know I’m right

3 Likes

I will give it two or three months, and if it isnt resolved or given proper consideration, I will start to shop around and move my money elsewhere.

It’s not that I dont like Freetrade, but getting fobbed off is quite irritating.

9 Likes

Freetrade this better be sorted or you will get slapped with a soggy fish.

I don’t track my shares on spreadsheets accept dividents, interest etc so I can see what I made year on year but I don’t have time to mess about inputting every individual share.

Come on before I get mad cow disease

1 Like