Bought Tesla at $220, but at $238 I'm negative?

Hi everyone, I just wanted to post here as I’ve reached out to help but am waiting for a response to see what’s happening with this.

Basically, I purchased 109.8 Tesla shares at $220 in pounds, but for some reason it didn’t break even until it hit $240. I understand FX rates can fluctuate the price between £ and $, but surely a $20 dollar swing can’t be right to go green? On top of that. It’s now trading at $260. I check very often and when it was trading at this same price two months ago I was up by around 2.2k. However now at the same price, only two months later I’m only up by 1.1k, or at least over £800 less than I was then once I calculated it. Again, I understand fluctuating FX rates pound to dollar but from what I can see this has barely moved over the past two months in order for me to be missing such an amount of the gains that I had in such a small time?

Looking for someone to shed some light on this!

Cheers!

1 Like

Hey @03desilvad I’m going to DM you to get some more info.

Thanks,
Charlotte

2 Likes

How does the profit change when you flick from £ < – > $ ?

The exchange rate has gone from 1.26 to 1.34 ( 5.6% change ) in the last few months so that will.make a significant difference on a c. £20k investment.

3 Likes

Hi Charlotte, just trying to post screens but as a new user it says I can only post one which isn’t too helpful? Cheers!

1 Like

I just changed your trust level - you should be able to post screenshots now.

But also, as @Jim_mcgrain says, it might be to do with FX fluctuations. Does it look right when you change currency?

1 Like

Hey @Jim_mcgrain @Charlotte

So here’s the screenshots below, as you can see teslas price is almost back at its highest peak since July at which point my profit was over 1k more as reflected in my portfolio (Tesla is 95% of my portfolio so the other changes in that time would be very minute).

I believe when Tesla was last trading at $260 I was around 2.3k in profit, whereas now I only stand at around 1.3k even though it’s at the same price.

Would the FX change you mentioned be that drastic?

Cheers!

The FX rate change could be that drastic, yes. The dollar has decreased by about 9% against the pound since when your shares were purchased.

See

3 Likes

These things tend to balance out over a long enough time.

It’s worth mentioning the positive flipside. I like having a lot of USD exposure as much of my worth’s tied to sterling.

USD’s a ‘risk-off’ currency, so in the event of a crash there’s usually a flight to it.

1 Like

That’s because everything’s tied to the dollah but aren’t a good few countries trying to separate themselfs from it now?

Yes.

10.07.24 : 109 TSLA @ $263 : $28667
25.09.24 : 109 TSLA @ $260 : $28340

Converting to £s using the GBP/USD rate of the day:

10.07.24 : $28667 / 1.2788 : £22417
25.09.24 : $28340 / 1.3400 : £21149

3 Likes

Hi all, thanks for your clarity on this especially @Jim_mcgrain it’s really clear now that I’ve seen those calculations you gave. I guess I was being pretty naive as to what a difference the FX price makes even over a short period.

5 Likes

Why?

1 Like

Isn’t the exchange rate going to be similar? Granted FX fees could be lower but trying to understand what difference this would make.

1 Like

Wow do they have control over the usd to gbp conversion rate?

1 Like

I flagged the now you see me now you don’t contributor

1 Like